Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: The scary body

  1. #1

    The scary body

    I was much relieved to find a very detailed list of my symptoms here. Now, if i know myself from previous times, I might start thinking of the real reasons for my worries rather than made-up diseases. My brother and I, you see, both suffer from MS - the difference is that he has it, I don't. The funny thing is that, being 35 now, my chance of developing MS is well below 1%... the chance of getting, say, skin cancer is MUCH higher than that, and still I don't worry about that a second. That might be the next hypochondric project - who knows!

    Well, it started with a so-called piriformis syndrom, which is a nerve compression in the buttocks that some suffer from. Imagine the terror of discovering the half my leg was numb - and I mean numb like you could put a needle into it without feeling anything. It took forever to find out exactly what was wrong. The doctors generally communicated THAT they were certain that it was nothing serious, but not WHY. Now I know: it followed dermatomes, i.e. the extent of a perpiheral nerve and it came and went. All this, no other signs on a physical neuro exam and a CSF test makes it highly unlikely that it's something central.

    Anyhow... The problem is not per se that doctors are bad at communicating. I've had testicular cancer and HIV and god knows what over the years. I seems to invent new deseases as quickly as I need. The problem, I think, is a downside of civilized life: When you have real things to worry about, you worry about them, when you don't you tend to select something to worry about. I'm certain that people with real problems, provided they are still managable, have much less psychological problems by the very fact that their problems are tangible. For my part, turning thirty felt like being 18 and turning 50: That future that everything hinged on, that the plans that gave my life meaning relied on, seemed less certain. What if something came along, outside of my control, that just put an end to it all? That turned me from a person into a case-study?

    For me, psychodynamic therapy is the only choice - it might be different for others. I've looked into CBT, but honestly, I invented most of those cognitive tricks myself long ago. Every time you manage to cure your symptoms, there is a chance they don't come back, so I guess CBT is a good option but very likely you have to ask yourself some deeper questions in the end. I'm a scientist and work also with scientific methodology, and for me it is clear: if someone tells you that you worry _because_ of some imbalance in your brain, they're only half-right. Modern science is horribly bad at picking out half-truths and above all it is very biased by its methods: it can measure chemical imbalances but not the dynamics of the mind on a higher level, so it decides that the higher level does not exist. This is slowly changing however.

    The thing is that YES the brain is a biological and chemical machine, and depression etc. turns up as chemical imbalances. But would you accept the logic that the computer you dropped on the floor does not work because a broken electical connection on location X on the motherboard? Sort of, I guess... It's no doubt true! But it is also no doubt true that it doesn't work because you dropped the darn thing on the floor! How do you fix it? By repairing the connection or by not dropping it again? As you see, there is no real choice between these two things, they are different and complementary. The reasons why we are worrying may be unflattering and unpleasant and nearly impossible to find out. I sure haven't found it all out in my case. However, what I know is that if I just medicate myself and let myself be convinced that it is "because of a chemical imbalance" that will be my downfall in the end. One has to try to live a full life, which can be horribly hard, and only then can these so-called imbalances be gone for good.

    One thing that I think that this site has that I haven't seen as well in different places is the physical manifestations of neurotic illness. I've intellectually always thoughlt that the burning, dizziness, weird taste sensations, feeling of tightness around the back and so on, were due to some sort of neurochemical overload - but emotionally I haven't completely believed it. Something always told me "Good! So you managed to fool yourself: congratulations!" But I must bow to the empirical pressure: if a lot of people manage, to independently of me, list all my symptoms in detail, then that closes the deal.

    Best,
    Claes

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    96

    Re: The scary body

    Wow, Claesand

    You seem to be challenging quite a lot at the moment, I also get the idea that your quantitative research is nudging into the less exact (and less safe) qualitative, so as well as chicken and egg questions, such as which came first, the chemical imballance or the 'symptom', are you also beginning to ask 'symptom of what'?

    If you refer to me, indirectly, as a particular manifestation of neurotic illness, that's reasonable - I've been called similar before. However, I reserve the right to suggest that I am not. Denial? Quite possibly. But I am human first, bag of scary names second (a very distant second) as of course are you. One of the biggest scares about qualitative methodology for me is the need to step out of the name-and-numbers zone. Certainly puts the willies up me at least.

    Your post suggests to me a little more than a closed deal.

    Write more if you can

    Martin

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. Scary symptoms.....
    By Sheik N Shimmy in forum Symptoms
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 25-04-07, 22:34
  2. Scary Weather
    By Jimbo in forum General Anxiety / Generalised anxiety disorder (GAD)
    Replies: 19
    Last Post: 20-03-07, 11:37
  3. scary..
    By halfwayhome in forum General Anxiety / Generalised anxiety disorder (GAD)
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 27-12-06, 22:29
  4. This is scary! Hello!
    By kittikat in forum Introduce Yourself
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: 19-10-06, 23:07
  5. Scary day
    By dela in forum General Anxiety / Generalised anxiety disorder (GAD)
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 06-03-06, 18:18

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •