PDA

View Full Version : An insight into HA from an expert...



Justanutter
04-08-15, 13:26
Was going through old posts of a retired Dr who used to post on here in response to people - he was amazing. His name was (I use the past term as he was in his late 80s a few years ago, so assuming he may not be with us any longer...) RLR. Here's what he said about health anxiety - which is what I feel is most of the cause of it today - he's spot on....

Vigilence to concerns that one has a life-threatening illness or disease more typically originates from feelings of vulnerability from lack of self-confidence and self-concept.

People with health anxiety commonly envision their symptoms to be at the farthest end of the spectrum in terms of severity and it not only produces significant fear, but also a diminished outlook in general that can have an impact on motivation and sense of well-being.

The tendency to focus on severity of health problems has increased in recent decades due to greater information available on the internet and the use of this portal by healthcare agencies to increase proactive attention to individual health practices. Naturally, information about heart disease and cancer becomes a front and center topic. Realize, however, that statistics about cancer and heart disease indicating these diseases to be on the rise are misleading. Advances in technology which allow us to detect problems much earlier make it appear that the disease could exist anywhere in any person, which isn't true at all.

It's also critical to realize that changes to the structure of healthcare providers in general produces the need to market patients, if you see my point. Advertisments tend to suggest that you can never be too careful and that those subtle symptoms, or even no symptoms at all, could nevertheless suggest your health to be at risk. So it's no wonder that people are becoming increasingly anxious about their health.

I was in practice for more than 40 years as a physician and specialist. I'm here to tell you that there is no explosive growth taking place in terms of diseases. We're just getting better at detecting it earlier in the same average caseload that has in reality, remained fairly stable.

So take a breath and relax. Anxiety tends to produce fearfulness, which subsequently causes vigilence to a threat that cannot be identified. Thus, your mind will naturally seek to prompt any action necessary for you to feel safe once again. In other words, if the cause can't be identified, it can exist in any form and present itself at the most inopportune moment. The real truth is that you're unlikely to get cancer and the odds are far less than what the healthcare marketing group is working to make you believe.

Best regards,

Rutheford Rane, MD (ret.)

sial72
04-08-15, 13:57
Very interesting, thank you x

Zingara
04-08-15, 17:47
Thanks for posting this! Very helpful.

venusbluejeans
04-08-15, 17:59
we are not sure on the health of RLR, he has not logged in here since October 2013 and also his own Heart Palpatations forum, so to be honest it doesn't look good, but you never know he could surprise us all by logging back in

ricardo
04-08-15, 19:28
I find this interesting that a man who appeared to be very respected and helped many people,chose not to use his real name as plenty of research has been done to try and find this man, all coming to a dead end.

After googling quite a bit it definitely looks like he chose for it to be that way, so we will never know.

stk149
04-08-15, 20:09
Thanks for posting this :) Very reassuring.

pulisa
04-08-15, 20:57
I think that if a few more medics spoke from the heart about their own mental health issues then a lot more progress would be made with mental health treatment

Carnation
04-08-15, 21:22
Thank you for taking the time to post this. Very interesting and helpful. :)

swajj
05-08-15, 09:22
I actually copied one of his posts to gingerfish's thread yesterday. Is that where you saw his I'd mentioned? I did post mention it there. Yes, he was a very, very knowledgable doctor. I exchanged some private messages with him. His heart palpitations forum was very informative. He wrote about many different types of illnesses not just heart palpitations. He was a neurologist for many years. But the thing that made him stand out from most other doctors was he profound understanding of health anxiety. I believe he has passed away. He hasn't been around for a couple of years and he would be well into his 90's. Its a shame that his forum has disappeared as he posted there for much longer a far more often than he posted here.

Justanutter
05-08-15, 10:56
Swajj, no, actually I was searching for posts of his relating to ecg reliability as I remember how informative he was on heart stuff as well! Just seemed like a good all round physician and caring to boot!

Yes, I too assumed he must have passed away sadly and yes, it's a pity his forum has disappeared as it was so good. Have you tried getting into his posts on here since yesterday because now it seems we can't?

---------- Post added at 10:56 ---------- Previous post was at 10:55 ----------


I find this interesting that a man who appeared to be very respected and helped many people,chose not to use his real name as plenty of research has been done to try and find this man, all coming to a dead end.

After googling quite a bit it definitely looks like he chose for it to be that way, so we will never know.

Ricardo,

I didn't realise that it wasn't his real name. Must have had his reasons I suppose.

MyNameIsTerry
05-08-15, 11:21
Swajj, no, actually I was searching for posts of his relating to ecg reliability as I remember how informative he was on heart stuff as well! Just seemed like a good all round physician and caring to boot!

Yes, I too assumed he must have passed away sadly and yes, it's a pity his forum has disappeared as it was so good. Have you tried getting into his posts on here since yesterday because now it seems we can't?

Try again now as I tried it in the night when I saw your post and the Advanced Search option allowed me to access threads & posts all the way back to the first ones.

I sometimes get server messages on threads but sometimes they don't reappear.

swajj
05-08-15, 11:24
Hi justanutter, I tried after I read your post and yes I can get into his posts. He said on his forum that he didn't use his real name. I spent some time wondering if he was who he said he was but finally concluded that he was genuine. I still search for his posts here if I am concerned about different symptoms. I become less anxious after reading his responses to other people. I have yet to come across anyone here who has a better understanding of health anxiety and its physiological effects. I miss him and I didn't even know him.

---------- Post added at 19:54 ---------- Previous post was at 19:51 ----------

Yes I always use the advanced search option to search for his posts.

Justanutter
05-08-15, 14:04
Terry, thanks for that. I often refer to them as they are so informative and comforting, so that's good to know.


Swajj, yes, I miss him too! Even if he wasn't posting under his real name, I don't doubt he was a medical person. Maybe for ethical reasons as such, he didn't want to be recognised for who he really was. I guess we will never know now.

Would be good if we actually had a real doctor on here wouldn't it but I guess they wouldn't get a minute's peace!!! :D